This project is educational and Open Source. No code is copied from other emulators. Implementation based solely on technical documentation and permitted tests.
Fix: Fix PPU Creation in Cython Wrapper to Resolve Null Pointer
Summary
The diagnosis of Step 0141 revealed that theSegmentation Faultit happenedbeforefor any code to be executed withinrender_scanline(), which confirmed that the problem was in the Cython wrapper: the pointer to the C++ PPU object was null (nullptr). Builder fixed__cinit__ofPyPPUinppu.pyxadding diagnostic logs, robust checks, and explicit error handling to ensure that the C++ PPU instance is created correctly.
Hardware Concept
In a hybrid Python/C++ emulator, creating C++ objects from Python requires a Cython wrapper that acts as a bridge between both worlds. The Cython wrapper maintains a raw C++ pointer (cdef PPU* _ppu) that points to the actual instance of the object in C++ memory.
When Python calls a wrapper method (ex:ppu.step()), Cython translates the call to a direct invocation of the C++ method (ex:self._ppu.step()). If the pointer_ppuisNULL(null), trying to call a method on a null pointer causes aSegmentation Faultimmediate,beforethat any code within the C++ method can be executed.
The Cython builder (__cinit__) is responsible for creating the C++ instance usingnew PPU(...)and assign the resulting pointer toself._ppu. If this process fails silently or does not execute correctly, the pointer is left inNULLand all subsequent calls will fail with a crash.
Implementation
Builder fixed__cinit__ofPyPPUinsrc/core/cython/ppu.pyxto ensure the correct creation of the C++ instance and add security layers that prevent future silent crashes.
Modified components
- src/core/cython/ppu.pyx: Builder
__cinit__enhanced with diagnostic logs and robust verifications - src/core/cython/ppu.pyx: Destroyer
__dealloc__improved with logs and explicit assignment ofNULL
Changes applied
1. Builder__cinit__improved:
- Added diagnostic logs with
print()to track the creation of the object - Explicit verification that
mmu_wrapperdon't beNone - Explicitly extracting the raw C++ pointer from the MMU wrapper:
cdef mmu.MMU* mmu_ptr = (<PyMMU>mmu_wrapper)._mmu - Verifying that the MMU pointer is not null before creating the PPU
- Explicit verification after
new PPU(mmu_ptr)to ensure that the assignment was successful - Throwing descriptive exceptions (
ValueError,MemoryError) if something goes wrong
2. Destroyer__dealloc__improved:
- Added diagnostic logs to track object release
- Explicit assignment of
NULLafter releasing the object to avoid dangling pointers
Key code
def __cinit__(self, PyMMU mmu_wrapper):
print("[PyPPU __cinit__] Creating PPU instance in C++...")
# Verify that mmu_wrapper is not None
if mmu_wrapper is None:
raise ValueError("PyPPU: mmu_wrapper cannot be None")
# Extract the raw C++ pointer from the MMU wrapper
cdef mmu.MMU* mmu_ptr = (<PyMMU>mmu_wrapper)._mmu
# Security check: Make sure the MMU pointer is not null
if mmu_ptr == NULL:
raise ValueError("An attempt was made to create PyPPU with an invalid MMU wrapper (null pointer).")
# --- CRITICAL LINE ---
# Create the PPU instance in C++ and assign the pointer
self._ppu = new ppu.PPU(mmu_ptr)
# Security check: Make sure the creation was successful
if self._ppu == NULL:
raise MemoryError("Memory allocation for the PPU in C++ failed.")
print("[PyPPU __cinit__] C++ PPU instance created successfully.")
Affected Files
src/core/cython/ppu.pyx- Improved constructor and destructor with robust logs and checks
Tests and Verification
Diagnostic validation (Step 0141):
- The fact that the message
printfof Step 0141 was never executed confirmed that the crash occurred in the call to the method itself, not within it. - This definitely indicated that the pointer
self._ppuin the Cython wrapper it was null.
Next check (pending recompile):
- Recompile the C++ module:
.\rebuild_cpp.ps1 - Run the emulator:
python main.py roms/tetris.gb - Verify that the diagnostic logs appear:
[PyPPU __cinit__] Creating PPU instance in C++... - Verify that the
Segmentation Faulthas disappeared - Verify that rendering is working correctly
Sources consulted
- Cython Documentation:https://cython.readthedocs.io/- Memory and pointer management in Cython
- Cython Best Practices: Constructors and Destructors with C++ Objects
Educational Integrity
What I Understand Now
- Null pointers in Cython:When a C++ pointer in a Cython wrapper is null, any attempt to call a method on that pointer causes a
Segmentation Faultimmediately, before the code inside the method can be executed. - Diagnosis through absence of logs:If a
printfat the beginning of a method it is never executed, it means that the crash occurs at the invocation of the method itself, not within it. - Cython Builder:The method
__cinit__It is critical for the correct creation of C++ objects. You must explicitly verify thatnewwas successful and that the resulting pointer is not null. - Memory management:It is good practice to explicitly assign
NULLto a pointer after freeing it withdeleteto avoid dangling pointers.
What remains to be confirmed
- Execution verification:Confirm that after recompiling, the emulator runs without
Segmentation Faultand that the diagnostic logs appear correctly. - Functional rendering:Verify that PPU rendering works correctly now that the pointer is valid.
Hypotheses and Assumptions
Main hypothesis:The problem was in the Cython constructor, where the creation of the C++ object was not being checked correctly. With the added checks, the issue should be resolved.
Assumption:The previous constructor code already had the lineself._ppu = new ppu.PPU(mmu._mmu), but there was possibly a subtle problem in how the MMU pointer was accessed or in the order of operations. The added explicit checks should prevent any similar problems in the future.
Next Steps
- [ ] Recompile the C++ module with
.\rebuild_cpp.ps1 - [ ] Run the emulator and verify that the diagnostic logs appear
- [ ] Confirm that the
Segmentation Faulthas disappeared - [ ] Verify that rendering is working correctly
- [ ] If everything works, delete the production diagnostic logs (keep only in debug mode)